It's finally made a paper that's not WND, so I'll take a moment to point out a story of a woman with, if her family history's anything to go by, at least a 10-15 year life expectancy, whose living will states that she is not to be dehydrated to death, whose granddaughter has procured power of attorney for herself (I have no idea how legal things work -- it's been said in Wizbang and elsewhere that the judge never actually went to law school or passed the Bar; is that possible?) and decided that it's time for her grandmother to die. (Again, I am not a player in the story, I do not have first-hand knowledge, I'm just passing on what others have reported. A Freeperthread says that she's actually just been refusing to eat, and the nephew's never cared for her before, etc. Regardless of the true facts of the story, it's the people who have seen only the facts as presented above and said the granddaughter's right that worry me.)
I've heard economists and medical-related people (no doctors yet) argue that we should cut off healthcare for people over a certain age. They'll cite all sorts of statistics, saying that we spend such-and-such amount of money in medical care in the last 6 months of people's lives, and if we just cut them off, we could do so much more with that money. A good portion of Europe, apparently, if these advocates are to be believed, does that.
I've also got a priest, right-wing as anything, who argues that it's immoral to provide medical treatment for old people with pneumonia, because that's such a nice and easy way to die.
I must say, I wouldn't want my job to be telling the people, no, sorry, I don't care how much you want the treatment or how much you're willing to pay, you're over the mandatory retirement age, so we've decided it's better for you to die now.
(Of course, this is not new; there have long been complaints about hospices and hospitals, in this country and elsewhere, where they don't provide the care they contract for (on the basis that the person's going to die so they won't care), or someone (often a nurse who gets in trouble) hurries along people who they decide really should die sooner. And there have long been problems with living wills, such as in the case of Marjorie Nighbert, who then had second thoughts and asked for food and water, but was told that it would be illegal to be fed in opposition to her own living will. None of this is new. It's just getting more attention, which is a good thing.)
UPDATE: I seem to have left an open tag at the end, sorry. And, word on the street is, the woman referenced at the top has been moved to a hospital and is being given food and water again.
Recent Comments